“There seems to be a bias against Johnny Keyser … which I don’t really understand … Some professional vocalists are of the opinion that Johnny’s performances were far better than any of the other Idols in the competition. Some blame him for not catching the fainting Idolist on the stage… hey, when someone faints, you don’t always have a chance to catch him/her. Johnny was probably so concentrating on what he was doing ( singing for his life on Idol) that he probably didn’t realize someone was fainting. I think Johnny is by far the best in this season’s Idol competition.” ~ Rog
“I HOPE JOHNNY IS BROUGHT BACK…CAN YOU SAY THE TOTAL PACKAGE ? I WILL BE EXTREMELY DISAPPOINTED IF IT IS ONE OF THE OTHER 3 ESPECIALLY COWBOY RICHIE….ugh !” ~ Nurseforkids
“i agree! there’s something strange about how quickly johnny was eliminated. there must have been a mistake. the “four guys” thing was just to create drama- the producers really want johnny.” ~ Jasmine Clark
“if you think about it, the fact Johnny is in the list must mean its him. If he is just there for suspense, why add someone who was cut a round earlier? it must mean something. I bet his dismissal created a lot of fan feedback. the other three were just cut from our perspective…how would that create buzz on the same night? I think something happened during the round johnny was cut, and johnny was unfairly removed from consideration. either he was treated unfairly or the producers were told by polling you screwed up with this one. I am actually not a big johnny fan yet. But i expected him in the top 10.” ~ Mary
“I think the whole thing about bringing back a 13th guy is going to end in johnny coming back,cause the judges did eliminate the other three with reasoning in top 42.well,they couldn’t just say ”u see we made a mistake,and we wanna bring johnny back”!!!” ~ Armond
"I cant BELIEVE American Idol let you go!! im not watching this season anymore. I was rooting for you and i am just dumb founded they had the nerve to let you go. I will support you in your future with music, you have my vote always, on the show or not! I think everyone can agree with me on that!
“Wow…even on your worst day I don’t know how you didn’t make it through. Thought you were a shoe-in to the top 12. Not sure what the judges are listening to with some people they put through..but keep doing your thing man” ~ KeithLongoMusic